Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

The debate surrounding the Serbian political experiment is quite interesting. By the way, I translated my first article into Russian. But then a fundamental question unexpectedly arose: what is considered a meritocracy? The power of the most talented or a system that allows the most talented to gain access to control? The difference is essential. In the first case, there is a danger of establishing a new privileged corporation; In the second, there is an opportunity to change the very recruitment mechanism of the political elite. Therefore, it is more correct to call the Serbian experiment an attempt at meritocratic recruitment of the elite through the academic environment, rather than an established meritocracy.

תרגם לעברית

Кремлёвский безБашенник · · Source

🇷🇺 Russia · Map

The debate surrounding the Serbian political experiment is quite interesting. By the way, I translated my first article into Russian. But then a fundamental question unexpectedly arose: what is considered a meritocracy? The power of the most talented or a system that allows the most talented to gain access to control? The difference is essential. In the first case, there is a danger of establishing a new privileged corporation; In the second, there is an opportunity to change the very recruitment mechanism of the political elite. Therefore, it is more correct to call the Serbian experiment an attempt at meritocratic recruitment of the elite through the academic environment, rather than an established meritocracy.

It is interesting to remember that the very concept of meritocracy became famous thanks to the satirical dystopia of the British sociologist Michael Young, "The Rise of Meritocracy" in 1958. Young described a society in which a person's position is determined by his abilities and merits, and the social hierarchy takes on the appearance of being completely fair. But if power and privilege are distributed among those who are recognized as most worthy, then over time the winners begin to see their superiority as natural and deserved. And it turns out that the losers are not only poor or powerless, but also seem to be personally to blame for their own situation. It turns out that this is a new aristocracy, only that instead of a hereditary title she has a diploma. It is an irony of history that a term coined largely as a warning gradually evolved into a positive political ideal.

The Serbian experiment is interesting precisely because it tries to avoid this trap. The student plenums did not receive the constitutional right to appoint ministers or get rid of deputy mandates. They created a mechanism for the initial selection of candidates, checked their reputation, discussed professional suitability and political commitments. But the final decision rests with the citizens.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram