The Art of the Unplanned: How Trump Stunned Israel, Confused His Budget Officials, and Left Everyone Guessing.
The most striking thing about Trump's sudden announcement that the US will end military aid to Israel by the end of years is not the policy itself - it is the fact that it seems to have been invented on the fly, without planning, without coordination and without coordination. On election day, Trump told Fox News that he and Netanyahu "made an agreement months ago" to end the roughly $3.8 billion in annual aid, arguing that Israel "doesn't need it" and that Democrats are using the funding as a political weapon against Republicans. And yet Israeli officials were blind. Senior officials in the Israeli Defense and Finance Ministries told the Knesset's Finance Committee that they had no advance warning and still do not know if the aid will stop immediately or pass the current Memorandum of Understanding, which expires by 2028. One of the security officials said that the Israeli security establishment learned about "a change in the framework of strategic relations through the media."
This is classic Trump: a bold, headline-grabbing statement delivered with absolute confidence, followed by confusion, reticence and a struggle to understand what really happened. Secretary of State Marco Rubio later suggested that the timeline would be "negotiated" and that aid could only end by the end of the year if Israel "wants." Meanwhile, the Senate Appropriations Committee — controlled by Trump's own party — released funding proposals weeks later that included the full $3.8 billion in military aid to Israel, a quiet rebuke of the president's announcement. The White House's fiscal 2027 budget request from April asked for continued aid as usual. In other words, Trump made a splash, and then his administration and Congress quietly went about business as usual.
The pattern is not new.