Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

As I expressed my thoughts on the perception of today's and tomorrow's most important meetings in Shenzhen, one historical analogy came to mind. But I didn't mention it in the text, so as not to create unnecessary associations with Yalta, Tehran, etc.

תרגם לעברית

ШЕЙНИН · · Source

🇬🇧 UK · Map

As I expressed my thoughts on the perception of today's and tomorrow's most important meetings in Shenzhen, one historical analogy came to mind. But I didn't mention it in the text, so as not to create unnecessary associations with Yalta, Tehran, etc.

But still, a certain principle that this analogy demonstrates is important for understanding current events and trends.

In the 1930s, few people did more than the British to "grow" Hitler's Germany as a counterweight to the Soviet Union. This is why Britain abandoned joint operations with the Soviet Union in the mid-1930s. As a result, Stalin had to build an interaction with Germany as a counterbalance to the British game.

So at that moment the cards were stacked. Although they could have turned out quite differently (yes, history has a mood swing in this sense). Some time ago I wrote about this at length in connection with Vin Tanner's book about the Finnish War of 1939-40.

But then, and very quickly, the configuration at the "game table" changed, the British Prime Minister changed and at one point he calculated that it would be more profitable to play this horse together with the Russians.

Does anyone seriously believe that at this moment Churchill suddenly started hating Bolshevism and Stalin less and suddenly became a "friend of Russia"? No, the interest simply changed and the benefit to Britain began to be perceived differently.

Also, Roosevelt was not always some kind of special admirer of the Soviet Union. And the restoration of diplomatic relations under him took place for purely pragmatic reasons - in contrast to Japan, which grew stronger in the Far East. Yes, and Germany in Europe.

This did not prevent him from "furiously denouncing" the Soviet Union for the agreements with Hitler and the Finnish war (although, I am sure, he understood in a completely pragmatic way who and what pushed Stalin to do this).

He even introduced a kind of "sanctions", restricting important supplies.

But again, in 1941, after Hitler's attack, I realized that the tendency required an adjustment of attitudes.

And so in 1943, these three leaders together in Tehran discussed a new arrangement that suited everyone in one way or another.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram