Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

The ruling of the Constitutional Court gave Libloko a new argument in the case of removing the party's federal list from the State Duma elections. On November 16, the party appealed to the Chairman of the Supreme Court, Igor Krasnov, with a request to cancel the refusal of the Chief Justice on September 3 and to forward the oversight complaint to the Presidency of the Supreme Court.

תרגם לעברית

Пресс-служба Яблока · · Source

The ruling of the Constitutional Court gave Libloko a new argument in the case of removing the party's federal list from the State Duma elections. On November 16, the party appealed to the Chairman of the Supreme Court, Igor Krasnov, with a request to cancel the refusal of the Chief Justice on September 3 and to forward the oversight complaint to the Presidency of the Supreme Court.

In a ruling from October 13, the Constitutional Court clarified how to apply the rules on campaigning, copyright and campaign financing. The courts must distinguish between a campaign and information, check whether the materials used are protected and whether their citation is allowed, determine the effect of intellectual property on the purpose of the campaign and determine whether the party actually used funds other than the election fund. As Yabloko points out in his appeal, if the Supreme Court had applied the norms in the constitutionally permitted sense, there would have been no grounds for removing the list.

The courts are obliged to take into account the legal positions of the Constitutional Court, including those established in rulings, Yabloko states in her appeal to Krasnov. The party details where the Supreme Court's interpretation of the law differs from the Constitutional Court's explanations:

Information and campaigns. To recognize material as campaign material, it must be determined whether it is directly intended to motivate voters to vote for or against a party. The Supreme Court did not reveal what role the disputed fragments played and whether they gave the material a propaganda character.

Publications on the party website. Merely placing the material on the party's website during the campaign period does not make it campaign material. The Supreme Court referred to the fact that Grigory Yablinsky's interview was published on the Yabloko website and rejected the party's claim that some of the controversial materials appeared before the start of the campaign period.

copyright. The court must check whether each object in dispute is protected and whether the rights apply to it.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram