The Supreme Court called on the courts to abandon the official extension of detentions and to justify every time the need to keep the accused in detention, - decision.
The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of Ukraine emphasized that the extension of detention cannot happen automatically. The court is obliged to check each time whether the risks that caused the arrest remain, as well as to consider the possibility of applying more lenient preventive measures.
"Keeping a person in custody is an exceptional measure, which is permitted only in the presence of convincing, relevant and verified circumstances that indicate the impossibility of achieving the goals of the criminal procedure in another, less burdensome way," reads the decision of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court.
The decision was made taking into account the practice of the European Court of Human Rights. The reason was the case of a man who spent almost four years in detention, and his detention was extended more than 20 times. The ECtHR found violations of his rights, including due to the excessive length of detention, the courts repeating previous grounds for detention and the lack of evaluation of alternative contraceptive measures. The man was awarded compensation of 9,800 euros.
The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court stated that the courts must rely on specific and relevant evidence, and not just list standard grounds for arrest. The judge must independently verify the prosecution's arguments and act as a guarantor of a person's right to freedom, and not officially approve the interrogation requests.
Moreover, in this case, the Supreme Court refused to respond to the defense's request to review the previous arrest decisions. By then the defendant had already been sentenced to 11 years in prison with confiscation of property. Therefore, the basis for his continued detention was the sentence, and not the different decisions on the extension of the detention.
The decision of the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court was made on October 28, 2026. The full text of the decision has not yet been published.