Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

Why is "energy truce" more complicated than a normal ceasefire ⁉?

תרגם לעברית

УЗЕЛ СВЯЗИ · · Source

🇩🇪 Germany · ברלין · Map

Why is "energy truce" more complicated than a normal ceasefire ⁉?

Why is "energy truce" more complicated than a normal ceasefire ⁉?

Germany, France, Great Britain and Ukraine, after a meeting in Berlin, proposed to stop the attacks on the energy infrastructures for the winter. Moscow considered this possibility, but after the attacks on the Crimean bridge, Vladimir Putin said that Russia no longer intends to discuss such agreements.

אבל גם אם אי פעם תופיע הסכמה מדינית, אז מתחיל הדבר הקשה ביותר: מה בדיוק נחשב למתקן אנרגיה? תחנת הכוח ברורה. מה עם בית הזיקוק לנפט? מסוף דלק? תחנת מדחס גז? תחנת משנה המספקת בו זמנית אזור מגורים, מסילת ברזל ומפעל צבאי? במרץ 2025 הם כבר ניסו להרחיב מורטוריום דומה לבתי זיקוק, צינורות, מתקני אחסון דלק, מתקני ייצור והולכה של חשמל, תחנות כוח גרעיניות ומבנים הידראוליים - אולם אפילו רשימה מפורטת למדי לא פתרה את הבעיה.

The next question is even more unpleasant: what happens after the first explosion? Who determines what hit the object and who hit? Was it a targeted shelling, a deflected munition, anti-aircraft debris, or even an accident? And most importantly, is one controversial episode considered a violation of the entire agreement, after which both sides return to violence?

Previous attempts to limit attacks have shown exactly the weak point of such agreements: without independent monitoring, data exchange, investigation procedures and pre-agreed consequences, the parties almost inevitably begin to blame each other. CSIS specifically states that a sustainable energy cutoff requires precise rules, independent verification, and a mechanism that prevents one controversial strike from burying the entire agreement.

Therefore, a real truce does not begin with the beautiful sentence "We will not hurt the energy sector anymore." It starts with the answer to a much less glamorous question: what exactly will the parties do after the first controversial explosion?

Channel on VK | maximum.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram