Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

4 trillion impasse: who really needs a railway from Kuzbass to China via Altai and who will pay for it.

תרגם לעברית

Си Перезвонит · · Source

🇨🇳 China · Map

4 trillion impasse: who really needs a railway from Kuzbass to China via Altai and who will pay for it.

The news that laying a railway from Kuzbass Chetgol to China's Urumqi through the Altai Mountains will cost 4 trillion rubles looks like another monument to gintomania. Even if you don't quibble with the funny typo of the news agencies, which turned the estimated 39.1 million tons of cargo into "39.1 thousand tons" (which would cost about 100 million rubles per ton transported), the very structure of the future cargo flow put an end to the project's payback. Of the total transport volume by 2045, 96% will be coal - plus some coke, metals and fertilizers.

For Russia in its current form, this is a project with negative profitability, which benefits everyone but the Russian budget. Cutting tunnels and building bridges through the earthquake-prone Altai ridges for 4 trillion rubles to export coal is an economic absurdity for three reasons.

First, coal is a dying commodity: by the year 2045, which the authors of the calculations aim for, China will already have passed the peak of coal consumption due to its production, renewable energy sources and nuclear power plants. Second, the last point of the route is Xinjiang (Urumqi), which itself is one of the main coal mining regions of China, meaning that we are going to deliver coal, literally, to the Chinese "stalker's room". Third, the route relies on one monopoly buyer: having invested trillions in a pipeline with no alternative access to the sea, Russia will find itself in a position where Beijing will be able to dictate any discount on raw materials - Kuzbass coal miners will have nowhere to escape from this industry.

But for China, this story is a win-win option. Beijing gets a direct land corridor to Western Siberia through the narrow 55-kilometer isthmus between Kazakhstan and Mongolia, bypassing the transit risks of third countries.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram