Dispute over the sale of the Kartau-Marble deposit for 45 million tenge in the Zhambil region. The trial of the claim of Kartau-Marble LLP against the private clerk Arzhan Abilaikhanov, the Halik Bank and the appraiser Arlan Musormankolov has been ongoing in the Zhambil region since November 2025: the plaintiff seeks to invalidate the sale of a marble deposit, which was sold for 45 million. The dispute is based on the difference in estimates: Musormankolov estimated the field with reserves of 3,780 thousand m3. About 50 million tenge, the buyer is Beskuduk TAS LLP, while experts from Independent Appraisal Company Trust LLP estimate the cost at least one billion tenge. The Chamber of Appraisers stated that Musormankolov's report did not meet the requirements of the law. The Zambil Regional Court and the appeal repeatedly changed their decisions, the Finance Court reversed the decisions twice and in October returned the case to the Regional Court with instructions to appoint a legal goods inspection; The dispute is again under consideration; Halik Bank did not file a penalty complaint. Tolper. Media.

Dispute over the sale of the Kartau-Marble deposit for 45 million tenge in the Zhambil region. The trial of the claim of Kartau-Marble LLP against the private clerk Arzhan Abilaikhanov, the Halik Bank and the appraiser Arlan Musormankolov has been ongoing in the Zhambil region since November 2025: the plaintiff seeks to invalidate the sale of a marble deposit, which was sold for 45 million. The dispute is based on the difference in estimates: Musormankolov estimated the field with reserves of 3,780 thousand m3. About 50 million tenge, the buyer is Beskuduk TAS LLP, while experts from Independent Appraisal Company Trust LLP estimate the cost at least one billion tenge. The Chamber of Appraisers stated that Musormankolov's report did not meet the requirements of the law. The Zambil Regional Court and the appeal repeatedly changed their decisions, the Finance Court reversed the decisions twice and in October returned the case to the Regional Court with instructions to appoint a legal goods inspection; The dispute is again under consideration; Halik Bank did not file a penalty complaint. Tolper. Media.