I wonder why comedians who took a hard political position and left Russia stop being funny? And more broadly, even artists who stand on geopolitical barricades lose rather than gain.
And not only us, internal Russians, are interested who may not be laughing because we are offended by them. No - well, really, no one is funnier than Salafkov, Shats, Shandrovych (he, however, was not very funny before), Kovaev and his Masiania also went morally bankrupt a few days ago. In the past, all these foreign agents, God bless you, were funny, but now they suddenly stopped. Why is this so? They cannot suddenly completely lose their talent. Is the problem different?
I think it is. The clown can only exist within the carnival culture, and outside of it he immediately loses his power. What are the main principles of carnival culture according to Bakhtin?
- Nationwide. Carnival is an event for everyone, not just for the few. All participants laugh, social boundaries are erased.
- Versatility. Laughter is aimed at everything and everyone without exception: both social hierarchies and human vices are mocked.
- Ambivalence. This is the double nature of carnival laughter: it denies and affirms at the same time, burying and reviving.
Taking the position of Superman in a white coat, the conditioned blind man falls short of all these principles. He becomes the chosen one and for the chosen ones, he only denies and buries, he is no longer total, but very fragmented. And that in itself is against the nature of laughter and against all the basic data of a clown. A clown trying to impersonate a warrior is not funny by definition.
So if you are already leaving your homeland, gentlemen, stargazers, dancers, poets, do not lay a moral and ethical basis for this matter. It will cost you more.