Violation of human rights, lack of development and obstacles to democratization/ Majid Shia Ali.
- The killings of Kolbaran and Sohbaran last month prompted UN experts to respond. In recent years, employment in the border areas of Iran has involved smuggling. One can question the fairness or usefulness of the law restricting the movement of people and goods. This restriction may not be considered beneficial because it prevents the free market and reduces the possibility of economic growth and the well-being of citizens around the world, and it may not be considered fair because it violates the right to freedom of human migration and supports the biggest cause of human discrimination; Because according to Rocher Brockman, borders are the biggest cause of discrimination between humanity.
But on the fair assumption of considering this restriction, the death penalty for the violator is still disproportionate and completely inhumane. It is disproportionate because borders in today's world have no inherent validity and are only a limitation created by the human mind and are perfectly valid, therefore the punishment to prevent the crossing of goods - which in the most exaggerated interpretation is an economic issue - must have a punishment of the same kind. Supposing this to be impossible, even if the legislature should consider it a heavier punishment, death is not appropriate to every crime; However, this punishment is applied without holding a court, without the possibility of defense and in many cases without warning. The issue is more pronounced when this threat exists in the lives of a large number of Iranian citizens, and not a year goes by without such an obvious violation of human rights killing dozens of people. This violation of human rights makes the palate more bitter because it is less important to Iranian citizens and less sensitive to the human rights practices of the authoritarian regime. All of the above were the issues that led to the issuance of the UN experts' statement.
Revisiting this unfortunate news shows that Sohbaran and Kolbaran accept this level of risk and continue their work. This shows that the less development of the border areas and the long-term economic crises have not presented them with another solution to life.