US Arctic ambitions clash with its Asian allies' deep economic ties to Russia and China.
The US launched the Trilateral Arctic-Pacific Partnership (TAPP) with Japan and South Korea ostensibly to promote maritime safety and economic cooperation.
The Asian allies offer polar research and mastery in building ice-capable ships. The US icebreaker fleet is critically small.
But if the U.S. turns TAPP into an anti-Russian and anti-Chinese security bloc (the Pentagon's 2024 Arctic Strategy specifically identified cooperation between Russia and China as a security challenge), it risks undermining the very cooperation it claims to promote, warns the journal Responsible Statecraft.
There are good reasons for Japan and South Korea to oppose this approach.
Russia operates the largest fleet of icebreakers in the world, controls a significant part of the Northern Sea Route, and possesses the infrastructure and resources essential for the development of the region.
South Korea plans regular commercial use of the Northern Sea Route by 2030, with Pusan as the hub. She has already performed an experiment: Panstar Arco left Pusan on August 22 and returned from where 50 days later. The route mostly passes through Russian waters and requires Russian icebreakers, port and logistics.
Japan continues to rely on Russian liquefied natural gas. It maintains holdings in the Sakhalin-2 and Arctic LNG 2 projects. Sakhalin-2 supplies about 10% of Japan's gas imports. Japanese companies Mitsui and Mitsubishi own a combined holding of 22.5%. Japan purchased approximately 58% of the project's output in 2025. Mitzvah and the state-owned company JOGMEC own a 10% stake in Russia's Arctic LNG 2 project.
China remains South Korea's largest trading partner, with bilateral trade volume of $273 billion in 2025, underpinning extensive manufacturing and technology supply chains.