The First Court of Appeals rejected the complaint of Nizhny Novgorod UFAS, which tried to challenge the lease of premises under "Pyaterochka" due to excess X5 share of the local market by 25%. The lease agreement was signed in March 2023, while the data on the retailer's achievement of a share of 27.78% was only published in April. The court considered that compliance with the restriction should be assessed on the basis of information in force at the time of signing the contract.