Lawmakers in New York are set to intervene on the issue of "artificial intelligence hallucinations" in court documents. A bill has been introduced in the state senate that would put a judge at risk of facing impeachment proceedings due to fictitious legal references. The initiative concerns the credibility of the argument, but does not prohibit the use of algorithms in the preparation of decisions.
There is already reason for the initiative: American judges have at least three times acknowledged the presence in their rulings of precedents that never existed. In law, this is not a harmless inaccuracy. The judicial reference must support the legal claim in an actual case, otherwise the basis of the decision is invalid.
The project is currently under consideration, so it is too early to talk about the penalty imposed. But the very wording of the question changes the emphasis: a technological error is proposed to be assessed under the responsibility of the person who signed the decision. The reliability of a precedent must be verified regardless of how it was found.
Ξeconomics.