Radar Telegram alerts Open Radar

China - Socialism or Capitalism?

תרגם לעברית

Историк Кирилл Назаренко · · Source

🇨🇳 China · Map

China - Socialism or Capitalism?

China - Socialism or Capitalism?

For me, the most important question of our time is: Is China moving towards socialism or staying in capitalism? If the answer is socialism, then we can safely say that humanity is marching confidently into the future on the path of social progress, despite some problems (relatively small, on a world historical scale), such as the counter-revolution in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. If the answer is capitalism, then the crisis of this system is still inevitable, but humanity is moving along a more tortuous path than we would like.

It is difficult to answer this question in a short post. I will try to express some ideas that I will develop in the future.

First of all, socialism is not a state, but a process. This is a big step in the development of humanity "symmetrical" to the phase of transition from a pre-class society to a class society (which lasts thousands of years). It is understood that historical time is accelerating, but the transition from a class society to a classless society (communism) must take a long time.

China has billionaires, private enterprises, a job market and huge wealth gaps. So capitalism? But let's remember the Soviet Union in the 1920s. During the NEP, there was private trade, entrepreneurs, foreign franchises, and substantial property inequality. At the same time, the state maintained control over the most important economic mechanisms, including foreign concessions.

In 1925, it was still impossible to say with certainty what the final outcome of this process would be. The Samnoviks believed that the Soviet Union would degenerate into a normal bourgeois state, and they had reason to think so. Moreover, when industrialization began in the Soviet Union, many foreign observers wrote that it was not socialism, but state capitalism, or neo-feudalism ("the second serfdom of the Bolsheviks"), or Asian tyranny. This is also what allegedly left-wing politicians wrote like that.

Furthermore, the life of an ordinary person in the Soviet Union in the 1930s.

More on Radar

Want to see every report in real time?

Hundreds of sources worldwide, translated into your language, with alerts for what matters to you.

Sign up free
Share on WhatsApp Get alerts on Telegram